Progressive Christianity

Progressive Christianity is a modern theological movement that seeks to reinterpret traditional Christian beliefs, often in light of contemporary cultural, social, and political trends. It generally emphasizes social justice, inclusivity, and a flexible, evolving understanding of Christian doctrine. While its proponents argue that Progressive Christianity aligns with the core principles of Jesus’ teachings, many in the historic Christian tradition consider it a form of heresy because it often denies or significantly alters key doctrines of orthodox Christianity, particularly regarding the authority of Scripture, the nature of Christ, sin, and salvation.

History of Progressive Christianity

1. Roots in Liberal Theology (19th Century): The roots of Progressive Christianity lie in liberal theology, which emerged in the 19th century, particularly through the influence of theologians such as Friedrich Schleiermacher and Albrecht Ritschl. These thinkers emphasized human experience and reason over traditional dogma, attempting to reconcile Christianity with modern science, philosophy, and ethical standards. They sought to de-emphasize the supernatural elements of Christianity, such as miracles and divine revelation, in favor of a more moralistic and experiential faith centered on the ethical teachings of Jesus.

2. 20th Century Developments: In the early 20th century, the Social Gospel movement—inspired by figures like Walter Rauschenbusch—further emphasized social justice, advocating for societal reforms based on Christian principles, particularly around issues of poverty, labor rights, and economic justice. While the Social Gospel had some positive contributions to addressing social issues, it often downplayed or even ignored core doctrines of sin, atonement, and salvation, focusing instead on the transformational aspects of society rather than individual salvation.

   In the mid-20th century, liberal theologians such as Paul Tillich and Rudolf Bultmann contributed to the development of a demythologized Christianity, which reinterpreted traditional Christian concepts (e.g., resurrection, atonement) in symbolic or metaphorical terms, rather than as historical and supernatural realities.

3. The Emergence of Progressive Christianity (Late 20th and Early 21st Century): Progressive Christianity as a distinct movement began to emerge in the late 20th century, especially in the wake of postmodernism and the decline of mainline Protestant denominations. It gained momentum in the early 21st century, often positioning itself as an alternative to conservative evangelicalism.

   Key figures associated with Progressive Christianity include thinkers like Marcus Borg, John Shelby Spong, and Brian McLaren. These leaders advocated for a reimagining of the Christian faith that accommodated modern sensibilities, particularly regarding issues such as gender equality, LGBTQ+ inclusion, environmentalism, and racial justice. This movement has found a home in many mainline Protestant churches, particularly in the Episcopal Church, the United Church of Christ, and parts of the Methodist and Presbyterian denominations.

Theology of Progressive Christianity

Progressive Christianity significantly reinterprets or departs from traditional Christian doctrines. Some of the key theological characteristics of the movement include:

1. A Low View of Scripture: Progressive Christians often reject the inerrancy and infallibility of the Bible, viewing Scripture as a human document that reflects the cultural norms and biases of its time. Instead of seeing the Bible as the divinely inspired and authoritative Word of God, they interpret it as a spiritual guide that can be reinterpreted in light of modern understandings of ethics, science, and culture.

   For example, they may affirm the moral teachings of Jesus, particularly on love and justice, but dismiss or reinterpret passages that deal with sin, judgment, or sexual ethics. This approach often leads to the selective application of Scripture, with Progressive Christians accepting some parts of the Bible while rejecting others.

2. Denial of Core Christian Doctrines: Progressive Christianity often denies or redefines key doctrines of orthodox Christianity, such as:

   • The Deity of Christ: While some Progressive Christians may affirm that Jesus was in some sense "divine," they typically reject the orthodox teaching that Jesus is fully God and fully man, coequal with the Father and the Holy Spirit in the Trinity. Instead, Jesus is often seen as a moral example or spiritual teacher, not the unique Savior of the world.

   • The Atonement: Progressive Christianity frequently rejects the traditional doctrine of penal substitutionary atonement, which teaches that Jesus' death on the cross paid the penalty for human sin. Instead, they may interpret the atonement metaphorically, as an expression of God's love or a call to self-sacrificial living. Some view the idea of Jesus' death as a sacrifice for sin as barbaric or outdated.

   • The Resurrection: The bodily resurrection of Jesus is often denied or reinterpreted as a metaphor for spiritual renewal or the ongoing power of Jesus' teachings. Some Progressive Christians see the resurrection as a symbolic narrative, rather than a historical event.

3. Universalism and Inclusivism: Many Progressive Christians lean toward universalism, the belief that all people will be saved regardless of their faith in Christ. This view is often tied to the rejection of traditional doctrines of hell and eternal judgment. Instead of viewing Jesus as the exclusive way to salvation (John 14:6; Acts 4:12), Progressive Christianity often promotes an inclusivist theology, where all sincere religious paths are seen as valid ways to experience the divine.

   This leads to a minimization of the need for evangelism or conversion, as Progressive Christians generally reject the idea that faith in Christ is necessary for salvation. Instead, they focus on social justice as the primary means of living out the faith.

4. Focus on Social Justice and Activism: One of the hallmarks of Progressive Christianity is its emphasis on social justice and activism, often aligning with secular movements for racial equality, LGBTQ+ inclusion, economic justice, climate change, and feminism. While concern for justice is a biblical principle, Progressive Christianity often places social issues at the center of the faith, sometimes to the exclusion of traditional doctrines related to sin, salvation, and eternal life.

   In this framework, the gospel is often redefined as liberation from systemic oppression rather than the forgiveness of sins and reconciliation with God through Christ.

5. Embracing Pluralism: Progressive Christianity is typically pluralistic in its approach to other religions, often affirming that all religions contain truth and are valid ways to experience God. This stands in contrast to the historic Christian teaching that Jesus Christ is the only way to salvation (John 14:6; Acts 4:12). Many Progressive Christians are open to integrating ideas from Buddhism, Hinduism, or other religious traditions into their spirituality, reflecting a syncretistic approach to faith.

6. Rejection of Traditional Sexual Ethics: Progressive Christianity frequently rejects traditional Christian teachings on sexuality, particularly regarding marriage and sexual ethics. It often affirms same-sex marriage and gender fluidity, arguing that the biblical prohibitions against homosexuality and other sexual behaviors are culturally conditioned and not relevant to modern society. This is a key area where Progressive Christianity diverges from the moral teachings upheld by orthodox Christianity.

Why Progressive Christianity is Considered Heretical

From a historic Christian perspective, Progressive Christianity is often considered heretical because it undermines or rejects core doctrines that are foundational to the Christian faith. Several key reasons for this assessment include:

1. Denial of the Authority and Inerrancy of Scripture: Historic Christian orthodoxy holds that the Bible is the inspired, inerrant, and authoritative Word of God (2 Timothy 3:16; 2 Peter 1:21). The rejection of the Bible’s full authority by Progressive Christianity leads to subjective interpretations and a pick-and-choose approach to Scripture, which undermines the consistent and coherent truth revealed in God’s Word.

2. Rejection of Key Doctrines: Progressive Christianity’s denial of essential doctrines—such as the deity of Christ, the atonement, and the resurrection—places it outside of the bounds of orthodox Christianity. The Nicene Creed (325 AD) and the Apostles' Creed affirm the full divinity of Christ, His death for sins, His bodily resurrection, and the necessity of faith in Him for salvation. Progressive Christianity often rejects or reinterprets these doctrines in ways that contradict the historic Christian confessions.

3. Minimizing or Redefining Sin and Salvation: Progressive Christianity often downplays the biblical teaching on sin and salvation. The Bible teaches that all humans are sinful and need salvation through Jesus Christ (Romans 3:23; John 3:16-18). Progressive Christianity, by shifting the focus away from individual sin and toward societal transformation, fails to address the central problem of human sin and the need for repentance and redemption through Christ’s atoning work.

4. Universalism and Rejection of Hell: The widespread acceptance of universalism in Progressive Christianity contradicts the clear biblical teaching that salvation is through Christ alone and that there is a judgment for those who reject Him (Matthew 25:31-46; John 14:6). While God’s mercy is great, Scripture teaches the reality of hell and eternal separation from God for those who do not repent and believe (Revelation 20:11-15).

5. Undermining the Exclusivity of Christ: The affirmation of religious pluralism and the rejection of Christ’s unique role as the only Savior in Progressive Christianity contradicts clear biblical teaching (John 14:6; Acts 4:12). Historic Christian orthodoxy insists that Jesus is the only way to God, and any teaching that suggests otherwise is considered a fundamental departure from the gospel.

The Historic Christian Orthodox View

The historic Christian orthodox view is built upon key doctrines that are affirmed in Scripture, the ecumenical creeds (e.g., Nicene, Apostles’, Chalcedonian), and the teachings of the early church fathers. These include:

1. The Authority of Scripture: Historic Christianity teaches that the Bible is the inspired and inerrant Word of God, fully authoritative in all matters of faith and practice (2 Timothy 3:16-17; John 17:17). Believers are called to submit to the whole counsel of Scripture, interpreting it in light of its clear teaching, rather than reshaping it according to cultural trends.

2. The Deity of Christ: Orthodox Christianity affirms that Jesus Christ is fully God and fully man—the second person of the Trinity who took on human flesh to redeem sinners (John 1:1, 14; Colossians 2:9). His unique identity as God incarnate is central to Christian salvation.

3. The Atonement and Resurrection: Christian orthodoxy holds that Jesus’ death on the cross was a substitutionary sacrifice for sin (Isaiah 53:4-6; 1 Peter 3:18). His bodily resurrection is a historical event that guarantees eternal life for those who believe (1 Corinthians 15:12-22). These doctrines are essential for understanding how God deals with sin and provides salvation.

4. The Exclusivity of Christ: The Bible teaches that Jesus is the only way to salvation (John 14:6; Acts 4:12). Salvation is available to all people, but it is only through faith in Christ that anyone can be reconciled to God. This exclusive claim is foundational to the gospel and cannot be compromised without undermining the Christian faith.

5. Salvation by Grace through Faith: Orthodox Christianity teaches that salvation is by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone (Ephesians 2:8-9). Human efforts or societal transformations cannot save; only faith in Christ’s finished work can reconcile sinners to a holy God.

Conclusion

Progressive Christianity represents a significant departure from historic Christian orthodoxy, as it denies or reinterprets essential Christian doctrines, particularly concerning the authority of Scripture, the person of Christ, and the nature of sin and salvation. By embracing cultural relativism, pluralism, and a focus on social justice at the expense of traditional doctrinal beliefs, Progressive Christianity undermines the biblical gospel. In contrast, the historic Christian faith affirms the unchanging truth of God’s Word, the unique saving work of Jesus Christ, and the call to repentance and faith as the path to eternal life.

-----

Relate Resources @Monergism