Relativism is the belief that truth and morality are subjective, varying based on individual or cultural perspective, without universal standards to define what is right, wrong, true, or false. Emerging prominently in the 20th century alongside postmodernism, relativism reacts against Enlightenment ideas of objective truth, instead asserting that all knowledge is context-dependent, fluid, and shaped by individual or group experiences. This ideology implies that human nature is self-determining, capable of creating personal "truths" shaped by circumstances rather than an objective standard.
Relativism seeks to implement its worldview by fostering an attitude of tolerance toward all beliefs as equally valid, often opposing any claims to absolute truth. In practice, however, this perspective leads to inconsistencies, as people who embrace relativism often judge others’ views, particularly on issues of social justice, which implies a standard beyond personal preference.
Christian Critique of Relativism
Christianity fundamentally opposes relativism, affirming that truth is absolute and rooted in God’s character. Jesus’ statement, “I am the way, the truth, and the life” (John 14:6), reveals that truth is neither flexible nor subjective but a reflection of God’s unchanging nature. The Bible teaches that God’s Word is the ultimate standard for morality and truth (Psalm 119:160), providing a timeless foundation that transcends cultural shifts. While relativism claims to promote tolerance, Christianity offers genuine respect for individuals without compromising on objective truth.
The biblical account of human nature acknowledges the reality of sin, showing that humanity tends to distort or suppress truth without divine guidance (Romans 1:18-25). In contrast to relativism’s view that individuals define truth, Christianity teaches that true freedom comes from knowing the truth that God reveals and aligning one’s life with His will (John 8:32). Additionally, Christianity responds to the universal human need for justice, love, and purpose, providing a stable foundation for human dignity, justice, and moral accountability that relativism lacks.
Several key flaws expose relativism’s internal contradictions:
Self-Refuting Nature: Relativism claims that all truth is subjective, yet this assertion itself is absolute, undercutting its foundation.
Inability to Condemn Injustice: Without objective standards, relativism cannot universally consistently condemn actions like oppression, whereas Christianity condemns such wrongs based on God's moral law.
Moral Obligation: While Christianity argues that moral obligations are universal (Romans 2:15), relativism fails to explain why people feel morally bound to uphold values, especially ones they expect others to uphold.
Reliance on Preference: Relativism bases morality on personal or cultural preference, lacking any authority or standard to compel the behavior of others, while Christianity upholds a transcendent, God-given standard.
Failure to Reflect Human Conscience: Christianity teaches that the conscience reflects God’s law, aligning with the universal human experience of guilt and moral awareness.
Relativism claims that truth and morality are subjective, varying by individual or culture, yet adherents almost always make universal moral assertions—such as advocating tolerance—which contradicts their premise that no absolute moral standards exist. This inconsistency reveals relativism’s instability, as it relies on universal truths to function meaningfully. By contrast, the Christian worldview offers an objective moral foundation grounded in God’s nature, providing coherence and a basis for genuine moral accountability, justice, moral obligation, and purpose, where relativism falls short.
In summary, relativism fails to uphold its claims: it denies absolutes but implicitly requires standards to argue for tolerance and morality. Christianity alone provides a consistent understanding of truth and human nature, grounded in a personal, unchanging God who embodies truth and extends grace to humanity.
-----