Legalism

Legalism is a heresy and a distortion of Christian doctrine that arises when obedience to the law or human-made rules is elevated to a partial, central or exclusive means of obtaining salvation, righteousness, or favor with God. Legalism can manifest in various ways, but it typically involves the belief that human effort, particularly through strict adherence to religious laws or moral rules, is either necessary for salvation or a means to earn God’s acceptance. This teaching undermines the biblical doctrine of grace, which affirms that salvation comes through faith in Christ alone, apart from works.

History of Legalism

1. Early Christian Church and Judaizers: Legalism is not new to the Christian faith—it emerged in the earliest days of the church. The Apostle Paul dealt with legalistic tendencies among Jewish Christians, especially the Judaizers, who insisted that Gentile converts to Christianity had to follow the Mosaic Law, particularly the practice of circumcision, in order to be saved. In Galatians, Paul vehemently opposed this view, arguing that salvation is by grace through faith in Christ, not by works of the law (Galatians 2:16; 3:10-11). Paul’s letter to the Galatians is essentially a treatise against legalism, as he defends the freedom of the gospel against those who sought to add legal requirements to salvation.

2. Medieval Church and Works Righteousness: During the Middle Ages, legalistic tendencies reappeared in the form of works righteousness within the medieval church. The Roman Catholic Church increasingly emphasized the necessity of participating in the sacramental system, performing good works, and penances as means to earn or increase grace. The selling of indulgences, where people believed they could pay money to the church to reduce time in purgatory, was one of the most egregious examples of this legalistic distortion of grace.

3. The Reformation Response: The Protestant Reformation in the 16th century, led by figures like Martin Luther and John Calvin, was largely a reaction against the legalism of the medieval church. Reformers emphasized sola fide (faith alone) and sola gratia (grace alone), asserting that salvation comes through faith in Christ’s finished work, not by human efforts or adherence to religious laws. Luther’s doctrine of justification by faith alone was a direct challenge to the legalism that had permeated the medieval church.

4. Pietism and Legalistic Tendencies: In the centuries following the Reformation, certain movements within Protestantism, such as Pietism in the 17th and 18th centuries, emphasized personal holiness and sanctification. While many Pietists were faithful to the gospel of grace, some expressions of Pietism veered toward moralistic legalism, where outward behaviors and strict adherence to rules became the primary markers of one’s spiritual state. This often led to a judgmental or self-righteous attitude toward others who did not conform to the same external standards.

Theology of Legalism

Legalism distorts several key biblical doctrines by replacing the grace of God with human effort as the basis for salvation or sanctification. Key theological points of legalism include:

1. Salvation by Works: At its core, legalism teaches that salvation is either wholly or partially dependent on human effort. While legalists might affirm the importance of faith, they insist that certain works of the law or moral behaviors are required to either earn salvation or maintain it. This denies the sufficiency of Christ’s atoning work on the cross. Legalism often adds extra-biblical rules or misinterprets biblical commands, turning them into a system of salvation by works.

2. Righteousness Based on Human Achievement: Legalism promotes the idea that a person’s righteousness is based on personal achievement rather than on the imputed righteousness of Christ. This leads to a mentality where Christians measure their worth and spiritual standing by how well they adhere to a set of laws or moral codes. As a result, legalists often become self-righteous, believing that their good works earn them favor with God, or they fall into despair, feeling that they can never do enough to please God.

3. Denial of Grace as Sufficient: Legalism undermines the biblical doctrine of grace by implying that God’s grace alone is insufficient for salvation. In legalistic thinking, something must be added to grace—whether it’s law-keeping, rituals, or moral performance—to make one acceptable before God. This is contrary to the New Testament teaching that "by grace you have been saved, through faith" (Ephesians 2:8-9), and that "Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes" (Romans 10:4).

4. Judgmentalism and Self-Righteousness: Legalism fosters a judgmental spirit, where individuals or communities evaluate others based on their adherence to external laws or standards. Those who do not conform to these standards are often deemed inferior or unspiritual, creating division within the church. Legalism also leads to hypocrisy, as people attempt to outwardly follow rules without a genuine inward transformation by the Holy Spirit.

Why Legalism is Heretical

Legalism is heretical because it denies the sufficiency of Christ's atoning work and elevates human effort as a necessary component of salvation. Several reasons for this condemnation include:

1. Denial of Justification by Faith Alone: One of the central doctrines of the Christian faith, affirmed in Scripture and by historic Christian orthodoxy, is justification by faith alone (Romans 3:28; Galatians 2:16). Legalism contradicts this by teaching that works or adherence to certain laws are necessary for justification. The Council of Trent (1545-1563) during the Counter-Reformation rejected the Reformers' teaching on justification, but the Reformed tradition has upheld that faith in Christ's atoning work is the sole basis for salvation.

2. Undermining of Grace: Legalism fundamentally undermines the doctrine of grace, which teaches that salvation is a free gift of God that cannot be earned by human merit (Ephesians 2:8-9; Titus 3:5). Legalists teach that grace must be supplemented by human works, effectively nullifying the biblical teaching that Christ's work on the cross is sufficient for salvation.

3. Misinterpretation of the Role of the Law: Legalism misunderstands the role of the Mosaic Law in the life of the believer. According to orthodox Christian theology, the law was given to reveal human sinfulness and our need for a Savior (Galatians 3:24). The law points to Christ, who perfectly fulfilled it. Legalism, however, attempts to use the law as a means of salvation rather than as a guide for Christian living in response to the grace already received.

4. Promotes a Works-Based Righteousness: Legalism leads to a works-based view of righteousness, where salvation and sanctification are understood as the result of human achievement rather than the work of the Holy Spirit in a believer’s life. This is contrary to the teaching of Romans 8:1-4, which states that the law's requirements are fulfilled in us by the Spirit, not by human effort.

Historic Christian Orthodox View

The historic Christian view, rooted in Scripture and reaffirmed in the Protestant Reformation, teaches that salvation is by grace alone through faith alone in the finished work of Christ. Key elements of this doctrine include:

1. Justification by Faith Alone (Sola Fide): The doctrine of justification by faith alone is central to historic Christian orthodoxy, particularly in Reformed theology. This teaching asserts that sinners are justified (declared righteous) before God solely through faith in Jesus Christ and his atoning sacrifice, not by any works of the law (Romans 3:28; Galatians 2:16).

2. Salvation by Grace Alone (Sola Gratia): Orthodox Christianity teaches that salvation is a gift of God's grace—unmerited favor—given freely to those who believe in Christ (Ephesians 2:8-9). No human works or effort can contribute to salvation, and it is entirely dependent on God's gracious initiative and Christ’s redemptive work on the cross.

3. Good Works as the Fruit of Salvation: While works cannot save, the Bible teaches that good works are the fruit of salvation, not the cause (Ephesians 2:10; James 2:14-17). Christians are called to live holy lives, but this is a response to the grace they have received, not a means to earn favor with God. The Holy Spirit empowers believers to walk in obedience, but their acceptance before God rests solely on Christ’s righteousness, not their own.

Modern-Day Iterations of Legalism

Legalism continues to appear in various forms in contemporary Christianity, though it often takes more subtle or nuanced expressions than in the past. Some modern examples include:

1. Moralistic Christianity: In many evangelical and conservative Christian circles, legalism can take the form of moralism, where emphasis is placed on strict adherence to moral or behavioral codes (such as abstaining from alcohol, following specific dress codes, or maintaining certain cultural practices) as the primary indicator of one's spiritual standing. This leads to a culture of judgmentalism and a works-based understanding of righteousness.

2. Pharisaical Church Cultures: Some church communities can become overly focused on external behaviors, often promoting a checklist Christianity where spiritual maturity is measured by how well individuals conform to specific standards. This can include rules about things like worship styles, Bible reading habits, or specific lifestyle choices that are not central to the gospel.

3. Fundamentalism: Certain branches of Christian fundamentalism are prone to legalistic tendencies, particularly in their emphasis on rigid adherence to specific rules regarding dress, entertainment, and social behavior. These rules are often presented as necessary for maintaining one’s standing before God, even though they may go beyond biblical commands. Legalism in fundamentalism can foster a performance-based faith, where outward compliance is prioritized over heart transformation.

4. Prosperity Gospel: Though the prosperity gospel is primarily focused on material blessings, it can also exhibit legalistic elements by teaching that God’s favor, healing, or blessings are contingent on human actions, such as giving money, making declarations, or practicing certain formulas. This conditionality reflects a legalistic mindset, where God's blessings are seen as rewards for good works rather than gifts of grace.

5. Holiness Movements: Some holiness movements have unintentionally fallen into legalism by emphasizing outward standards of holiness (such as abstaining from makeup, jewelry, or certain forms of entertainment) as necessary for maintaining one's salvation. While these movements often emphasize sincere devotion, they can easily slip into a form of legalism when external behaviors become the primary means of measuring one’s righteousness.

Conclusion

Legalism is a heresy that distorts the gospel of grace by emphasizing human effort and works as necessary for salvation, undermining the doctrine of justification by faith alone. It has appeared throughout church history, from the Judaizers in the early church to the medieval Roman Catholic Church and beyond. Legalism elevates rule-keeping above grace, leading to self-righteousness, judgmentalism, and a misunderstanding of the role of good works in the Christian life. While legalism continues to appear in various forms today, particularly in moralistic or fundamentalist expressions of Christianity, the historic Christian orthodox view affirms that salvation is a gift of grace, received through faith in Christ, and that good works are the fruit of this salvation, not its cause.

Related Resources @Monergism