Monergism

  • Home
  • Directory
  • Our Faith
  • MP3s
  • Bookstore
  • Donate
  • About Us
  • Contact

Directory of Theology

Subscribe to Updates

| New Links | Editors' Picks | Popular Links

Critiques of NPP

Home >> New Perspective >>


NPP writers generally hold that Paul was in agreement with the main points of contemporary Jewish soteriology. His quarrel with the law and Judaism was not with legalism as articulated by the Protestant Reformers, but with either the Jewish denial of Christ as Messiah (Sanders’ position) or, as in the case of Dunn and Wright, that Judaism was dominated by ethnocentric tendencies. These tendencies were influencing Jewish Christians over against Gentile Christians. In this case Paul was not exercised about matters of salvation—at least not directly. Being the apostle to the Gentiles, Paul was concerned with the burning question of how Gentile Christians were to be accepted into the church. In his original context, then, Paul addressed his teaching of justification by faith at the problem of racial and religious/ethnic segregation. Salvation was not the issue. ! Since Paul is not, or at least not primarily, using “justification” to address the problem of salvation by works, it follows that justification cannot be thought of as an element of soteriology— or least not as central to the gospel. The question that Paul is considering in the matter of justification is not “How can I be saved?” but “How can I be in or know that I am in the covenant people of God?” Justification is now thought to be less about soteriology and more about ecclesiology.We recognize that this summary of the NPP is extremely brief, but it captures the core of the NPP. What is evident about the NPP is that much rides on how we understand the soteriology of first century Judaism. (RCUS Synod Report)

Sort by:   Date added - Rating - Title

Title Notes
Paul and the Law in the Last Ten Years Douglas J. Moo (pdf)icon
The Fulfillment of the Law Thomas R. Schreiner - A paper presented at the Evangelical Theological Societyicon
Evaluating the New Perspective On Paul Cornelis P. Venema - 17 Articles tracing the development, theology and scholars associated with the New Perspective.icon
Excurus: Paul, "Works of the Law," and First-Centruy Judaism Douglas Moo - Romans 3:20 (NICNT)icon
Israel and the Law in Romans 5-11: Interaction with the New Perspective Douglas J. Moo (pdf)icon
Did Luther Hate the Law of God? Martin Luther - Excepts on the Lawicon
The Challenge Of The New Perspective To Biblical Justification (MP3) Al Mohler with guests John Piper and Ligon Duncan - What was at the heart of Paul's ministry and message? Recent attempts to redefine the very heart of Pauline theology make this a timely and critical issue.icon
John Piper Responds to Don Garlington on the Imputation of Righteousness John Pipericon
What is the New Perspective on Paul?: A Summary [Crash Course 1] Biblical Thoughticon
Indeed, Has Paul Really Said (.pdf) 1.89MB Pastor M. J. Beasleyicon
Justified Hesitation? J.D.G. Dunn vs. The Protestant Doctrine of Justification Lee Gatissicon
Abraham, Faith, and Works: Paul's Use of Scripture in Galatians 3:6-14 Moisés Silva (.pdf)icon
The New Perspective on Paul Big 3″: N.T. Wright [Crash Course 4] Biblical Thoughticon
The New Perspective on Paul - Part 2 Gary Gilleyicon
The Wrighteousness of God (.pdf) Gerald Bray Critiques N. T. Wrighticon
PCA Study Report on Federal Vision Report of Ad Interim Study Committee on Federal Vision, New Perspective, and Auburn Avenue Theologiesicon
Do We Need a New Perspective on Justification? Ligon Duncanicon
Five Arguments Against Future Justification According to Works (Part II) Rick Phillipsicon
Righteousness and the NPP Lee Ironsicon
The New Perspective on Justification Richard Phillipsicon
What Is At Stake? Guy Waters - An Assessment of Nicholas Perrin's Criticisms of Justification and the Perspectives on Paulicon
Some Thoughts on Covenant Theology and Justification Dr R Wardicon
The Sanders/Dunn "Fork in the Road" in the Current Controversy Faith by Robert L. Reymond, Ph.D.icon
What’s Wrong with Wright: Examining the New Perspective on Paul Phil Johnson (.PDF)icon
Report on Justification OPC (.Pdf) The Seventy-first General Assembly erected this Committee “to critique the teachings of the ‘ Perspective on Paul,’ ‘Federal Vision’ and other like teachings concerning the doctrine of justification ...icon
The Narrative of Scripture and Justification by Faith: A Still Fresher Reading of Paul Mark A. Seifrid (.Pdf)icon
Justification as Distinct from Sanctification Grover Gunnicon
Jesus' Perspective on Sola Fide John MacArthuricon
The Current Justification Controversy O. Palmer Robertsonicon
Calvin on the Pernicious Hypocrisy of Justification by Faith and Works their historic church confessionsicon
Pauline Theology of Law: Did Luther Get It Right? Thomas R. Schreinericon
'Works of Law' in Paul Thomas R. Schreiner - Novum Testamentum 33 (1991): 217-244.icon
The Abolition and Fulfillment of the Law in Paul Thomas R. Schreiner - Journal for the Study of the New Testament 35 (1989): 47-74.icon
Paul and Perfect Obedience to the Law: An Evaluation of the View of E. P. Sanders Thomas R. Schreiner, Westminster Theological Journal 47 (1985): 245-278.icon
Is Perfect Obedience to the Law Possible? A Re-examination of Galatians 3:10 Thomas R. Schreiner, The Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 27 (1984): 151-160.icon
Book Review: Justification and Variegated Nomism (Volume 1) Thomas R. Schreiner - Edited by D. A. Carson, P. T. O'Brien, and M. A. Seifridicon
The New Perspective on Justification Rick Phillips - a three-part series on the historical background and the NPP's teachings on justification and imputation.icon
Response to Bryan Chapell Rich Luskicon
N.T.Wright and the 'New Perspective' on Paul J. Ligon Duncan - SOME THOUGHTS ON COVENANT THEOLOGY & JUSTIFICATION icon
The Attractions of the New Perspective(s) on Paul J. Ligon Duncan - A Transcript of a paper given in Jackson, Mississippi and Glasgow, Scotland A very well crafted, effective response to Wrighticon
The Paradoxes of Paul Guy Waters - reviews Justification and Variegated Nomism, vol. 2.icon
Review: Justification and the New Perspectives on Paul Jeremy Smithicon
Tom Wright and the The New Perspective Paul Barnett takes a look at NT Wright’s views on salvation and justification.icon
The Eschatological Aspect of Justification James T. Dennison, Jricon
Covenant Confusion Rev. Richard Phillipsicon
Counted Righteous in Christ (Chapters 1-2) John Pipericon
Counted Righteous in Christ (Chapter 3) John Pipericon
Counted Righteous in Christ Chapter 4, Bibliography, Index John Pipericon
The Great Exchange Philip Eveson - Online Bookicon
The New Perspective on Paul: Calvin and N. T. Wright J. V. Fesko What makes the perspective most harmful to the church is its use of terminology.icon
Book Review N. T. Wright, What Saint Paul Really Said: Was Paul of Tarsus the Real Founder of Christianity? Brian G. Hedgesicon
Report of thr Special Committee to Study Justification in Light of the Current Justification Controversy Presented to the 258th Synod of the Reformed Church of the United Statesicon
N.T. Wright on Justification Charles E. Hillicon
Retreating to Rome: The New Battle Over Justification James W. Galyonicon
New Perspective of N. T. Wright David H. Linden, an elder of Bethel URC in Calgary, AB Canadaicon
E.P. Sanders and N.T Wright Ra McLaughlinicon
Tom Wright's View of Justification: An Ecmenical Interpretation of Paul Dr. Sidney D. Dyericon
A Man More Sinned Against than Sinning? Carl Truemanicon
Theology and Life: Pastoral Implications of the New Perspective Part I by Rev. Darren Middletonicon
Pastoral Implications of the New Perspectives (Part II) by Rev. Darren Middletonicon
Pastoral Implications of the New Perspective (Part III) Rev. Darren Middletonicon
Book Review: N.T Wright, “What St Paul Really Said” Rev Darren R Middletonicon
Has the Reformation misunderstood Paul? Doug Barnesicon
Justification by Faith Alone & Confessional Confusion Douglas R. Shiversicon
Justification by Faith in the Theology of Norman Shepherd Dr. David Van Drunenicon
Discussing Norman Shepherd Dr. R. Scott Clarkicon
Gaffin's Conference on Justification Doug Barnesicon
Tom Wright on Conversion Brian Robinsonicon
The Unconditional Covenant in Contemporary Debate Protestant Reformed Seminaryicon
A Historian's Perspective on the New Perspective Carl Trueman Associate Professor of Church History and Historical Theology Westminster Theological Seminary, Philadelphiaicon
Some Thoughts on Covenant Theology and Justification: Traditional Views The Presbyterian Benner - March 2002icon
Some Thoughts on Covenant Theology and Justificaiton: Modern Views The Presbyterian Banner - April 2002icon
Some Thoughts on Covenant Theology and Justification: More Modern Views terian Banner Rowland S. Wardicon
New Perspective on Justification (Part I) John G. Reisingericon
The "New Perspective" on Justification (Part Two) John G. Reisingericon
A Critique of the New Perspective on Justification (Part Three) John G. Reisingericon
Long Before Luther: Jesus and the Doctrine of Justification John MacArthuricon
New Views regarding Legalism and Exclusivism in Judaism: Is there a need to Reinterpret Paul? Gerhard H. Visscher.icon
Norman Shepherd and the Faith that Justifies E. Calvin Beisnericon
Romans 4:25 James T. Dennison, Jr.icon
Undeserved Grace Versus Strict and Deserving Obedience in Early Judaism A. Andrew Dasicon
Doctrinal Statement at the Trial of John O. Kinnaird Arthur W. Kuschkeicon
"Reformed" is Definitely Enough C. Matthew McMahon - A review of Douglas Wilson's "Reformed" is not Enoughicon
The History of the Interpretation of the Apostle Paul Dr. Peter M. Headicon
The New Perspective on Paul and Justification PCAs Monthly Umpired Debateicon
Interview with John Piper About The Future of Justification: A Response to N. T. Wright John Pipericon
The Role of Adam and Christ David H. Lindenicon
On Replying to Moralists (Like Tom Wright) R. Scott Clarkicon
Justification and the Diminishing Work of Christ John Pipericon
Justification: God's Plan and Paul's Vision Guy Waters reviews NT Wright's Justification: God's Plan and Paul's Visionicon
Paul's View of the Law in Romans 10:4-5 Thomas R. Schreiner - Westminster Theological Journal 55 (1993): 113-135.icon
Paul and Perfect Obedience to the Law: An Evaluation of the View of E. P. Sanders Thomas R. Schreiner - Westminster Theological Journal 47 (1985): 245-278.icon
Is Perfect Obedience to the Law Possible? A Re-examination of Galatians 3:10 Thomas R. Schreiner- The Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 27 (1984): 151-160.icon
Jesus' Perspective on Sola Fide John MacArthuricon
The New Perspective on Paul Louis DeBoericon
Jesus, Islam, Pharisees, and the New Perspective on Paul John Pipericon
What Did Paul Really Mean? Simon Gathercoleicon
Virtue That Counts A Christianity Today editorial | posted 7/13/2007icon
More Concerns about N.T. Wright J. Ligon Duncan III - Divine monergism at work in regeneration and justification has a vital role in sanctification.icon
The New Perspective on Paul - Part 1 Gary Gilleyicon
Dj Vu All Over Again Michael Hortonicon
Whose Obedience? Or Elementary, My Dear Christian R. Scott Clarkicon
The New Perspective on Paul - Part 3 Gary Gilleyicon
PCA GA Report on the FV/NPP R. Scott Clarkicon
The New Perspective on Paul Big 3″: E. P. Sanders [Crash Course 2] Biblical Thoughticon
THE NEW PERSPECTIVE ON PAUL BIG 3: JAMES D. G. DUNN [CRASH COURSE 3] Biblical Thoughticon
Which Comes First? Paul Helmicon
Five Arguments Against Future Justification According to Works Rick Phillipsicon
The Narrative of Scripture and Justification by Faith: A Fresh Response to N.T. Wright Mark Seifridicon
The Mississippi Valley Presbytery (PCA) report (PDF) on the FV and NPP (.pdf) The Presbytery of the Mississippi Valley (PCA)icon
Origen on the righteousness of God Lee Ironsicon
Schreiner, Seifrid, and Vickers Assess Piper-Wright Debate at Boyce College Tom Schreiner, Mark Seifrid, Brian Vickersicon
Why Covenant Faithfulness is not Divine Righteousness (and cannot be) Paul Helmicon
Observations on N. T. Wrights Biblical Theology T. David Gordonicon
Where does N. T. Wright stand on the Atonement? Lee Ironsicon
Justification and Gods Righteousness: Imputation and the Future Hope Michael Hortonicon
Justification and Gods Righteousness: Covenant and Eschatology Mike Horton's review of N.. Wright's Justification, Part 5icon
What is the New Perspective on Paul? (MP3) R. Scott Clarkicon
Δικαιοσύνη Θεοῦ and N. T. Wright Daniel B. Wallaceicon
10-Part Review/Critique of N.T. Wright's Justification Michael Hortonicon
Book Review: Justification by N.T. Wright (.pdf) Reviewed by Dr. Michael Hortonicon
Sort by:   Date added - Rating - Title

Recommended Reading

Justification and the New Perspective
by Guy Prentiss Waters

Covenant, Justification, and Pastoral Ministry
Ed R. Scott Clark

Gospel of Free Acceptance in Christ
by Cornelis P. Venema

Similar Pages

Atonement (160)
Gospel (571)
Justification (425)
Union with Christ (53)

Newest Links

  • Republication of the Covenant of Works, Part 2
  • The Law is Not of Faith (MP3)
  • The Place of Daniel in Old Testament Eschatology (.pdf)
  • St. Paul in Macedonia (.pdf)
  • Aesthetics And The Place Of Beauty In Worship (.pdf)

SUBSCRIBE TO THE FEATURES BY EMAIL OR RSS

Top Rated Links

  • Monergistic Regeneration - Part 2
  • Sequential Interviewing Skills Part 6 (MP3)
  • Systematic Review and Verification of Applicant's Statements Part 7 (MP3)
  • The Economy of the Covenants Between God and Man:
  • Selecting the Appropriate Questions Part 4 (MP3)

Popular Links

  • Calvin's Commentaries on the Whole Bible
  • Expository Sermons from Genesis to Revelation
  • Classic Bible Commentaries
  • John Piper - Sermons by Scripture
  • IVP New Testament Commentaries

Users online: 61 | Tell Friend | Add to Favorites
Links: Popular | New | Pick | Top Rated | Random

Monergism Copyright © 2009 by CPR Foundation. All rights reserved  |  Site Credits